0.1633
900 319 0030
x

Nehru's Decision on India's UNSC Permanent Seat

iasparliament Logo
March 18, 2019

What is the issue?

  • Union Minister Arun Jaitley recently criticised India’s first PM Jawaharlal Nehru for declining a US proposal in 1950 on India's permanent seat in the UN Security Council.
  • It is imperative, in this context, to understand the strategic and political rationale behind Nehru's decision.

Click here to know more on India's claim to UNSC permanent seat.

What was the proposal?

  • The US made a proposal to India in August 1950 through the Indian Ambassador in the U.S.
  • It expressed the American desire to remove China from permanent membership of the UNSC and possibly replace it with India.
  • Nehru allegedly refused to take this suggestion seriously and thus abdicated India’s opportunity to become a permanent member of the UNSC.
  • However, the complexity of the international situation might justify Nehru's stance then.

What was the international situation?

  • The above events took place in August 1950 when the Cold War was in its early stages.
  • The two superpowers were in eyeball-to-eyeball confrontation that threatened nuclear catastrophe.
  • The People’s Republic of China had just emerged from a bloody civil war and was seen at the time as the Soviets’ closest ally.
  • It was prevented from taking its permanent seat in the UNSC because of American opposition based on Cold War logic.
  • Furthermore, war was intense in the Korean peninsula.
  • The U.S. and allied troops were locked in fierce combat with North Korean forces supported by China and the Soviet Union.

What was Nehru's rationale?

  • Nehru, at that time, was trying to carve a policy that ensured India’s security, strategic autonomy and state-led industrialisation.
  • He anticipated that pushing China out, as the U.S. wished to do, would result in a perpetual conflict that could engulf all of Asia.
  • To him, the Korean War appeared a forerunner to more such conflicts in Asia that could even turn nuclear.
  • The U.S. had dropped nuclear bombs on Japan only 5 years ago and it would possibly not hesitate to do so again in an Asian conflict.
  • This is especially since nuclear deterrence had not become a recognised reality then.
  • So given these, Nehru did not want India to get embroiled in hazardous Cold War conflicts as it would risk India's own security.
  • He understood that peace could not be assured in Asia without accommodating a potential great power like China.
  • Nehru also felt that China had to be provided with proper place in the international system.

Why is Nehru's decision justified?

  • To be precise, America's proposal was not an offer but merely a vague sensor to explore Indian reactions to such a contingency.
  • The U.S. intended the offer to be a bait to attract India into an alliance with the West against the Sino-Soviet bloc.
  • The US aimed at pulling India into the “defence” organisations that it was setting up in Asia to contain the presumed “Communist expansionism”.
  • Nehru was well aware of this and the fact that Washington was only interested in using India for its own ends.
  • Had India accepted the American bait, it would have meant enduring enmity with China without the achievement of a permanent seat in the UNSC.
  • Moreover, even if accepted, the Soviet Union, then China’s closest ally, would have vetoed such move.
  • As, it would have required amendment of the UN Charter that is subject to the veto of the permanent members.
  • It would have also strained the relations between India and the Soviet Union, affecting the possibility of a close political and military relationship with Moscow later.
  • The ties, in fact, became necessary once the U.S. entered into an alliance relationship with Pakistan.
  • Moreover, the Indo-Soviet relationship paid immense dividends to India during the Bangladesh war of 1971.

 

Source: The Hindu

Login or Register to Post Comments
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to review.

ARCHIVES

MONTH/YEARWISE ARCHIVES

Free UPSC Interview Guidance Programme