0.1553
900 319 0030
x

Understanding the Polarisation in Kashmir

iasparliament Logo
April 26, 2018

What is the issue?

  • Various incidents in Kashmir valley have spotted some long-term dynamics and regional differences in J&K.

What is the account of diversified ethnic groups in J&K?

  • Kashmiri speakers - Muslims and Hindu/Pundits; these people view themselves more cultured and articulate voice of the state (valley based).
  • Non-Kashmiri speakers - These groups are from the erstwhile State of J&K.
  • They claim themselves the ‘Kashmiri’ in India, Pakistan, or in the diaspora (non-valley based).
  • Gujjars groups -Bakherwals are the third-largest ethnic group in the State.
  • They have always lived on the margins of society because of their nomadic lifestyle.
  • These people, ethnically, culturally, and linguistically would otherwise identify more with the Jammu region.
  • Ladakhis - These people are indigenous ethnic groups of the Leh-Ladakh region.
  • They live in the most remote parts of the state.

What are the prevailing regional differences in J&K?

  • Valley-based Kashmiris feel it hard to acknowledge the presence and aspirations of other ethnic and identity groups in the State.
  • Most of the Bakherwals fear their marginalisation in an autonomous political set-up.
  • They are keen on getting some institutional assurance of their recognition as groups separate from the Valley Kashmiris.
  • Hindu communal sentiment operating within the broader right-wing nationalist framework has also been visible to bring the State under one flag and one Constitution.
  • The sense of deprivation and discrimination at the hands of the Valley and the communal sentiment have fed into each other.
  • With no institutional mechanisms to redress the former, the latter narrative has become predominant.
  • The binary of a Hindu-Jammu is dispossessed of its rightful share of resources and political power by a Muslim-Kashmir.
  • The broader national-level communal polarisation has reduced it to Hindu versus Muslim, in which any Muslim gets bracketed with the Kashmiris.

What are the reasons for increasing conflicts in J&K?

  • Lack of better educational and economic facilities in other regions of the State made Jammu city the focal point of migration over the last two decades.
  • Even Ladakhis who logically should go to the Kashmir valley, given its geographical proximity, prefer Jammu for their higher education.
  • Due to better access to education and creeping urbanisation, many of them are settling down, especially in Jammu city and its adjoining districts.
  • These are the areas where there has historically been a distrust of the Kashmir Valley.
  • This is because of the real and perceived neglect by the political leadership of the State which has always been Valley-based.
  • The political parties have served to increase this divide as it resulted in a political vacuum in which there is no voice to speak for both regions and all communities.
  • Thus the nativist sentiment that it has engendered is fuelled by the already present communal fault lines in the region.

What is the way forward?

  • Given the historical and socio-economic dynamics, it is inevitable that Jammu city would be where different groups would move.
  • The argument of demographic change does not make much sense if looked at in the broader context of the whole State.
  • As people who are moving to the Jammu region are only citizens of J&K itself.
  • It makes sense only if Jammu city and its adjoining areas are seen as a political entity separate from the rest of the State.
  • In fact, the forces working towards the division of the State have become more proactive in recent times.
  • And so this has heightened the question of demography.
  • Relations between various ethnic groups in Kashmir need to be nurtured to curb political and unhealthy agendas.

 

Source: The Hindu

Login or Register to Post Comments
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to review.

ARCHIVES

MONTH/YEARWISE ARCHIVES

Free UPSC Interview Guidance Programme