Full time Teaching
Faculty for Mathematics

Learn More

Inclusion of Electricity in GST

December 07, 2017
11 months

What is the issue?

With transitional implementation challenges with the GST being sorted out, it is a high priority now that electricity is included in GST.

What is the current status?

  • Currently, there is a confusing multiplicity of electricity taxes.
  • Notably, the taxes vary by states and across user categories, low for consumers, high for industrial users, etc.
  • Taxes levied by the states vary from 0 to 25% and is an important source of revenue for them.
  • On average, electricity taxes account for about 3% of own tax revenues of the states, going up to close to 9% in some states.
  • States are, therefore, reluctant to give up the right to levy these taxes.

What are the concerns?

  • Costs - The most serious concern is that costs to industrial users of electricity are higher.
  • This is because they include the taxes on inputs that have gone into the supply of electricity.
  • These include taxes on raw materials (coal, renewables) and other equipment (solar panels and batteries).
  • Not being part of GST means that no inputs tax credit can be claimed.
  • This certainly results in embedding of the tax in the final price.
  • Embedding of taxes - This clearly hurts manufacturers selling to the domestic market.
  • In particular, this affects the exporters of electricity-intensive products.
  • It is because they are not liable to any duty drawback i.e. relief for taxes embedded in exports.
  • Industrial buyers of electricity bear the impact of this in an indirect way.
  • Populist politics has long ensured that consumers (and other users in agriculture) pay either nothing for electricity or very little.
  • Ultimately, discoms cross-subsidise and charge higher prices to industrial users to make up for under-charging others.
  • But the embedding of taxes adds an extra layer of cross-subsidisation.
  • Totalling up all of these effects could lead to increased costs and lower margins for several industries.
  • These margins are significant, especially for exporters who face strong international competition.
  • GST - Currently, there is a large bias in favour of renewables in GST policy.
  • Inputs to renewables generation attract a GST rate of 5% while inputs to thermal generation attract higher rates of 18%.
  • Supporting renewables might be a conscious policy.
  • But subsidisation is proliferating across policy instruments, making it difficult to quantify the overall support and is thus distorting.
  • Thus, support for renewables should be direct and transparent.
  • GST should not become the instrument for adding non-transparently to that support.

What could possibly be done?

  • GST - If electricity is included in GST, there would be no discrimination between renewables and thermal energy.
  • This is because all inputs going into both forms of electricity generation would receive tax credits.
  • Including electricity in GST would also reduce or eliminate embedded taxes in electricity-using products.
  • Loss - But both the central and state governments would lose revenues that would now accrue as input tax credits to the private sector.
  • In addition, state governments would lose taxes from electricity use itself.
  • The Centre could thus compensate the states only for the direct loss of revenues.
  • However, benefits of the reforms would be greater to be shared between the Centre and the states.
  • Implementation - To ensure that Centre does not suffer fiscal losses, the implementation with electricity should perhaps wait until GST revenues have stabilised.
  • Inclusion of electricity in the GST would thus -
  1. reduce the costs for manufacturing
  2. improve the competitiveness of exporters
  3. reduce the cross-subsidisation of electricity tariffs that further undermines the competitiveness of manufacturers and exporters
  4. eliminate biases and restore neutrality of incentives in electricity generation


Source: Indian Express

Login or Register to Post Comments
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to review.